Technically this was my second Vipassana
course, but as per the rules this was my first. This so happened that in the
year 2019, I registered for a 10 days course. Whatever the ups and downs there
were I was on the 9th day. I was excited and happy that the treacherous
journey was coming to an end, and here and there I thought I experienced
something different, and spent some time like a monk. So I have split this
write-up into parts, first time and second time.
First Time
Early morning after our breakfast, I was just
strolling, examining myself, trying not to entangled in the excitement of
finally meeting my family and sharing my experiences with friends and family.
This was exactly what we were trying to learn, to understand everything is
transitory, clinging to these impermanent thing is the root cause of
unhappiness. The emergency alarm bell rang incessantly and everyone hurried to
the meditation hall. We were told that lockdown had been announced in Victoria,
and the course had to be called off, noble silence ceased with that
announcement.
On the 8th day I had a fleeting
thought that the course was ending, and a wish lighted, I wished there were few
more days. Only from 7th day I had actually started liking it. I was
settled down, think past the pain in the body or should I say rest my mind once
in a while and loose a sense of space and time.
So on 9th day we returned home with
a very brief closure. As I look back the ego had already taken over, I was
elated, excited and what not. This happiness unfortunately was not for the experience,
not for learning new thing, not for discovering something in me of which I was
unaware. Reflections now tell me, I had neither learnt new thing, discovered
nothing new about myself or had a taste of any nectar. I returned home happy
and calm. This calmness was again not because I had discovered anything but
just hangover of 9 days of complete silence, strict routine, and lack of
interaction. There was no new version of me. That was reality and I will try to
get into some details. But this is about me, my observations of people, of
things and my interpretation so simply put my truth.
Before I move on to my latest 10 days course, I
should still elaborate on my first experience. I was excited and I had
expectations too. At that time, I had become health conscious, I was running
every morning, kept a track of what I was eating and was in a very positive
state of mind having lost 10+ kg in a mere 2 months. Vipassana was another
milestone. I had heard about Vipassana for a long time, back home I was in
Nepal. Once even enquired the possibility of registering but that for some
reason didn’t materialize. The impetus this time were the books I was reading, I
had completed all three books by Yuval Noah Harari and was impressed. He had
dedicated one of his books to S.N. Goenka who set into motion the long lost
Vipassana technique.
Though any sort of exercise is prohibited,
walking was allowed and since I didn’t want to give up my running journey, I
would always be walking briskly between the breaks, stretching my body or
perhaps doing Surya-Namaskar and all. On the third day the manager told me
gently that with those activities I might not grab the full benefits of
Vipassana, and that is when I stopped those regiment. I would still walk but
this time with mindfulness and awareness. This gave me time to introspect, look
at things and remove some weeds from my sub-conscious, revisit and revise my
perspectives, it was really nice. That continued for the entire stay. While
these reflections outside the meditation sessions were nice, they were also
interfering with the meditation. These introspections brought so many things in
forefront and my mind will be busy with those, it was overwhelming to deal with
the flux of memories. Even during meditation settings my mind won’t calm. This
led to frustration and all, eventually on 7th day I was at peace. During
the breaks when I used to walk, I would rather focus on what was in front of
me, looked at the milieu, the grass I was walking on, the birds, the rabbits,
insects rather than anything personal. I would be back indulging in self reflections
but as soon as I realized I would divert my mind.
When I looked at other people I couldn’t help
but judge them. They looked so sad and many of them looked like addicts, mental
patients. They were expressionless, I wouldn’t say calm but I realized it was
error of judgement as I was comparing them and their visible attributes with
the excitement, happiness that was within myself. es with the excitement,
happiness that was within myself. I was happy
I was happy when I was not in the meditation hall. In the
meditation hall it was boring, the mind was flying like a kite whose thread had
been broken and there was no one controlling it. It will move with the wind, no
direction of its own. A minute looked like an hour and I would be desperately
waiting for the gong to go off. Strangely I was however able to maintain a
stable posture throughout the sessions. It was very funny when those who sat
around me told me on the 9th day that I seemed to be the only one
who was reaping the benefits of meditation and always at trance. I was able to
fake it.
1st day passed almost without much
notice, I was simply excited for the experience that awaited (which never
came), the boredom started to pick from 2nd day. The anapana thing still
made sense but it was boring, I had already getting the proper sensations where
I was expected, repeating it was loathsome. 3rd day I was
questioning my decision, I was convinced this technique made no sense. The only
thing I was convinced will help me was getting off the grid i.e. the digital
detoxication and the silence. The meditation and the discourse were the real
illusion rather than those SN Goenka was talking about in his discourse. I didn’t
go to the meditation hall in one of the sessions when the teacher won’t be
there. I basically slept in my dorm. I told myself let me wait till 5th
day as Vipassana was yet to start and that might have different experience.
4th day afternoon Vipassana started.
That morning also I had not attended the morning session the one before the
breakfast. Vipassana was a new thing so 4th day passed easily but
during the discourse I was back with my doubts. But I told myself that I will
give it a fair try on 5th day. There were many students who had
already taken the course, so I argued with myself if they had not found
anything beneficial why would they come again. When I looked at my fellow
meditators they seemed to be enjoying it. It was only me, the impatient me.
5th day was a little bit of change,
it was not so boring and I would still wait for the gong to go off but unlike
previous days I wouldn’t be desperate. But that remained just for half of the
day, it was becoming unbearable, and the body ache was making it worse.
The worst was the 6th day. I was
agitated, with myself for making such a blunder. I was sitting there doing
nothing, I was not able to concentrate, struggling to calm my mind and to bring
it in control or alternatively simply not care what my mind was doing.
What was the point I was asking, I could have
rather stayed home, that would have been more relaxing. Shun my mobile,
internet at home and just read books, spend time with my daughter and wife it
would have been more meaningful and yet I had put myself through this torture.
Now I was determined during the lunch I will tell the co-ordinator that I
wanted to go. While having lunch my ego was hurt, what would my friends say, my
relatives say. They will laugh at me, after all that hullabaloo I had given up.
The ego supressed everything and the second round of determination took over.
This determination was to save my ego and nothing else.
Day 7, at 4:30 AM I was in the hall, in a lotus
posture upright and resolute. Perhaps was sleeping through that session too. I
didn’t think much about it during the breakfast, washed some cloth that didn’t
even need washing just to save myself from indulging in silly thoughts and dive
into memories web. Strangely the 8:00-9:00 session was much easier to the
extent that I thought I had experienced something different, and this was what
I was meant to experience. The experience must have been for 5 minutes or even
less but I thought it was worth it. Now when I remember it, it could have been a
small moment of peace, happiness or tranquil after so many days of confusion,
irritation. As soon as I experienced it and it had been swept into the
memories, I retrieved it immediately sugar-coated it. The experience that was a
simple happy moment was now the promised joy, the nectar, the bliss and the
connection to the universe. This was simply the mind playing the game, and I
was enjoying it. Perhaps that was enough for me give up on the idea of
quitting. I was telling myself, oh the bliss is true, I can’t quit now. I have
to taste it again, this will be liberation, the joy. Basically I was happy to
just assume to break the new shackles and chain myself with new one. Oh human conditions.
8th day I was already worried that
the course was ending, only two days were left. Then on 9th we had to
leave.
On my way home I was glad I made it, I had
stories of my experiences to tell, I was overflowing with excitement. That 5
minutes of good feeling had washed away 6 days of pain, irritation and doubt.
This I thought was what keeps us living. We might be pessimistic at conscious
level but at the subconscious level we still have expectations of reward or
perhaps its simply the fear of death that we keep living.
I told my wife and daughter about my
experiences, poured my memories to my friends. Everything good was said yet not
forgetting to telling again and again it was painful and how the survival is
difficult. I was basically telling them how I was tough, I was someone who didn’t
give up, I went through adversity and triumphed. After fanning my ego, I still
had to reconcile with the reality, those 9 days were like dreams and we live in
reality not in dreams. Next morning I woke up little disconnected. It felt
empty, I felt out-of-place. I was not stopping yesterday and yet today I didn’t
know what to speak about. I felt that was not the reality or was confused what
reality actually was. All my life my priorities had been that of a common man,
I loved my family, I enjoyed sensual pleasures, I relished in good food, I was elated
on success and felt worthless on failures, my own value was the value the
society gave me. That was my reality in the last 9 days I was told that was old
thought pattern and the reason of misery. Rather than experiencer we should simply
be observer and always be aware that everything is impermanent. So reconciling
was difficult. A seemingly reasonable self of mine was telling me this was
reality, 9 days were dream, I live in society and with my family, if I falter
my family will suffer. I cannot simply give-up things and become a monk, even
the course did not want me to do that. But how do I practice impermanence and
equanimity in this life where I have to pay mortgage, I have people who depend
on me, I have to earn to live, participating in competition is not a choice,
the rat race is not a choice and on top of that I am an average man, risk
averse, with worldly attachments.
At work it felt same, people seem to be
speaking through me, seeing through me at times. I could not concentrate, and
could not pick from where I had left. Many things seemed new, vague. It was not
peace, it was more chaos. It took me few more days to get back in real, but I
was back.
Many others seemed to have felt the same. To
satisfy my ego I can say the course changed me, I started looking at things
objectively. I can say I am less effective by events, by glory and by gloom but
I would be lying. Many a time to validate what we did we make things up, we
hype the experience, we sugarcoat events and people. I have done that, that is
just our intrinsic nature, we can’t change it and it is not our fault. We have
been made so by thousand and thousands years of evolution, mutation it can’t
change easily in 10 days. Small changes here and there might come but we have
to be conscious every time on every action of ours. How many times do we do
things knowing it is not the right thing even when we are actually doing it? We
might have yelled at our Children, just realizing this is not right when we are
actually yelling. It seems helpless. It is very difficult but I think I am
convinced that there is no free will yet in day to day life I blame myself and
others as if they did it on volition.
Second time
I wanted to complete the course and I had
missed it by a day. We were told we had actually completed the course, and we
can do the same thing at home that we had done on the 8th day. Again
the ego was not satisfied so I had registered for the course. I was on the
waiting list and as the days got closer and closer, I had started becoming
indifferent on whether I will be accepted or not. My wife didn’t want me to go
this time as we needed to change many things specially around our daughter.
Perhaps that was one of the reasons why I was indifferent to the acceptance
this time around. Eventually I got the confirmation, and that didn’t trigger
any excitement or sadness. Either I knew in my subconscious that I will be
accepted or may be I actually didn’t want to be accepted so the acceptance didn’t
bring any excitement. I was not sad either.
Unlike last time I didn’t do any preparation,
didn’t buy anything new, didn’t do any packing before an hour, and also went
lighter than last time. Two trousers, three tees, 3 under-wears, bodywash,
tooth-brush, tooth paste, an alarm clock, a pair of slipper, few pairs of socks
and a shorts. On my way I talked to my parents, my wife and my daughter. The
ask was to reach the meditation centre at 4:00 PM but I knew from the last time
that people arrived much later as well. I reached there at 3:45 PM. Called my
wife one last time before switching off and handing over the mobile phone to
the manager. It felt lighter, we have become slaves of technology. It took half
a million year for the human race to arrive at the age of Industrial Revolution
as if we had been slowly preparing ourselves for it. However in last two
centuries, we made so much progress that it might have been difficult to our
mind and to our body to adapt to it. Specially our mind, such that there is
always a conflict. When we settled for agriculture 10000 years back, we also
freed ourselves from always being at alert for food, for hunt, for protection.
Mind was not developed to be free, it always had to be at work, so when we
became free the mind started jumping between past and future. It got time to
compare, to wish, to crave, to cling and the predicament of human was
determined.
The course claims to have been developed by
Siddhartha Gotama himself, the Buddha, 2500 years ago. The course is about
mind, so even 2500 years earlier as well man was worried about mind or should I
say mind worried man. Perhaps their major concern that time was what they did
daily didn’t align with what was there in scripture. Despite knowing they were
not doing it the way their scripture wanted or their Gurus wanted they couldn’t
help themselves. They could not get rid of greed, lies, sexual misconduct,
hatred, violence, something kept pulling them to these defilements. Morality
was mostly guided by scriptures back then, men thought less independently. Now
with almost 8 billion human in Earth, struggling for resource among themselves
and with the nature the problem has simply multiplied. As consumerism keeps
growing, as celebrity culture keeps growing and the desire to show I am not any
less keeps growing the problems of mind keeps growing too.
This time I didn’t have any expectations and no
excitement. I knew from my previous experience that it was going to be
difficult but at the same time I knew I won’t be quitting. I was not looking for
any enlightenment or awakening because I no longer believed in those. I had
planned what I will do though. I thought away from the rest of the world, I
will introspect. This time I had assured myself, I won’t feel guilty for not being
able to concentrate and for loosing myself in memories. Basically I didn’t
carry any mental baggage. At the same time, I also promised that I will be more
serious in the process and give it a fair chance. Practice mindfulness as much
as possible when not in meditation.
One thing I didn’t want to do was to talk to
anyone on the day of arrival. We are social by instinct, we seek for others
like us, if I talk to anyone on the day 0, the chances of me looking for them
would be higher. No new connections. That went for a toss when I sat in my
assigned place for the dinner (On first day and the last day dinner is given).
Four of us sat around the same table and we introduced ourselves. Then there
was a brief orientation and shortly noble silence started. The only people I
could talk to was the manager and the teacher.
I was assigned a room and it was decent,
afterall I would only sleep in this room or take brief rest. I didn’t want to
meditate in the room because for me meditation in the room meant sleeping. My
alarm was set at 3:45 AM, though the gong will go off at 4:00 AM, I wanted to
wake up earlier and take a bath.
I didn’t have a good sleep and the alarm woke
me up at 3:45 AM. I was already in my room by 4:10 AM. The Gong went off at
4:00 AM, then again at 4:20 AM asking us to be at the meditation hall. I went
to the meditation hall. We started with “ana-pana” and it was easy to follow instruction
and I was finding sensations here and there. During “Ana-pana” the participants
are asked to try to feel the breathing or sensations it produces between the region
above the upper-lips and little above the nostrils. Though I could feel
sensations I was confused whether they were real sensations or I was simply
making those up.
The other thing that hit me hard was, I was no
longer able to sit in the same position with folded legs for more than 15
minutes. I had knee pain, numbness and all. I was getting older at faster rate.
It was irritating. Day 1 ended with no drama and nothing new. During intervals
I was walking slowly, mindfully and like a very weak person who had just
started walking. I didn’t spend anytime in introspection. I fell asleep
quickly.
Day 2 was not any different, at 6:30 we had
breakfast, as usual there was Porridge, yoghurt, cereals, fruits, soup made
from lemon, plum and peach. Then there were bread of various types jams, marmalade,
peanut butter, vegemite, butter etc along with tea, coffee, milk and so on. “Ana-pana”
continued, I kept struggling to keep myself still. I was still getting confused
on the sensations as there were too many and nothing consistent, but that is
what happens and expected as well, yet I was looking for a consistent sensation.
Just after first session past lunch, I sat
again for another round of “Ana-pana”, this time the sensation was same, the
location was same but I managed to think the experience was different. Ana-pana
is not supposed to bring you any experience but to help you concentrate and
prepare you for vipassana. It was momentary less than a minute but for some
unknown reason I liked it.
Day 3 was day 2 on repeat except that I didn’t
have any pleasant experience, and I was already getting bored. The worst thing
was my shoulder blades were in lot of pain. This pain was not letting me concentrate,
I stacked cushions, rested my hands and none seemed to help. Though I had no
feeling of leaving but I thought may be this is again a futile tryst. I then
asked myself what was I expecting, I didn’t have any expectations but that didn’t
mean I had anticipated this pain, I wasn’t expecting this pain either. My
introspection began after that, I was flying the kites of my memories higher
and higher. At times I was digging my memories harder and faster. There were
treasures of course, treasures of my childhood, of people, of heartbreaks. I
tried to remember so many things, so many events, so many people and followed
them wherever they led. There were immediate past and there were farther past.
This journey was not completed in a day, this journey continued over the period
of time perhaps till day 9.
Dreams were vivid, the characters came out of
any combination, they had no shame, no shyness, they were brute, they were
meaningless or they spoke or illustrated in signs and actions that were very
difficult to decipher. One day I saw a snake slithering over my chest, black,
spotted snake. I woke up frightened and then it took me a while to go back to
sleep.
Day 4 was just another day, except that the
vipassana session started after lunch. It was a very hot day, and it was dry.
The sky looked cruel, the hillocks on the other side seemed to be asking for
help. It was nasty. I also realised that I had been doing vipassana wrong all
the way from the first time. I felt like a fool. I was trying to follow the
sensations throughout my body and then scanning it with my eyes closed just
like the gatekeeper at the airport scans you with their instruments.
4th day was eventless in the sense
that I didn’t experience anything nor did I had any doubts on my decision to
join vipassana.
5th day was hotter, I didn’t even
want to open my eyes, everything looked so bright, so bright that it seemed
like burning. That day I missed home, I was sweating everywhere. After lunch I
sneaked into my room and turned the fan and sat there. The gong went off, and I
had to be hall. Its not the meditation that I didn’t want this time, the idea I
had to walk almost 2 minutes to the hall amidst the Sun scared me.
I was there in the hall with closed eyes and
with determination that had come out of nowhere. And when I opened my eyes
later I had memories of loosing the sense of space and time, as if floating. I
was not asleep and I knew that, where was I in that period and how long was
that period. My mind had played game is what I think. For sometime after that I
felt I could feel my neurons firing, there were sensations abundant of them. It
took a while for the gong to go off so I guess the moment was brief. This time
I didn’t want to get up, open my eyes, I wanted to sit as is. My shoulder
blades were in pain yet I could neglect that. I remained there for a while. My
brain was playing it big, then I realised it must be the sweat, the itchiness
and the stickiness.
That was one-off experience and never felt
anything similar. I was asking myself brain and mind are cause and effect. Mind
is created by brain, brain takes the inputs from senses and depending on the
action potential triggers so many things that might trigger an action, a
thought and thus the mind. In the meditation we were observing our sensations,
and our minds but then who is it that observes. Who puts an effort to observe
whats going on? So that’s consciousness. Now what is consciousness was my
question and I had two possibilities. One its just another effect of brain, so
the brain spawns two active workers one is the consciousness and the other is
mind. The consciousness is the superior worker, it’s the manager and it keeps a
check on mind, it also perhaps keeps a check on senses but ultimately reports
everything to brain. It is living while mind is just a slave. “Self” is then
combination of brain and this consciousness.
The other possibility is this consciousness is perhaps
a living and aware entity that the brain doesn’t have control over. When we are
alert, and living based on the livefeed from our surroundings putting the
memories on the back-seat we are living with consciousness and that is when we
can probably take the reigns in our hand. In this case, “self” is this
conscious entity.
Then what are we, mind or consciousness? It varies
moment after moment. For example, my daughter often comes to me for help with
her assignments, when I am working my response is more to get her off my back,
when I am free I look at her questions carefully perhaps even re-read it,
understand it and try to give her the solution. In the first case I am my mind
while in the later I am my consciousness.
I think most of us and certainly me are our
minds. From my example above living as a consciousness is more appealing, but I
can’t be sure because I believe almost all of us have always lived in our minds
and with our minds. We have survived and evolved as the most superior being in
the planet. Or is it that those negligible human who have lived on
consciousness or those negligible moments where we were consciousness made us
who we are and when we live on the mercy of our minds we are simply herds.
When do we live on consciousness then, when we
are in life threatening moment, when we are deeply engrossed in the sport we
are playing or the work we are doing etc.
Can we live on consciousness every moment? I am
not sure of this either it would be very resource (energy) intensive living or
may be we can train our mind. Does meditation do that? They say it does, I don’t
believe.
6th
day was relatively cooler in terms of weather but was the most miserable among
the days I spent this time around. I had played so much with the thoughts that
my mind was too excited like a child who had got a new toy. It was jumping with
joy and I couldn’t hold it still. I had all my energy wasted while my mind was
going wild, it was on steroids.
Remaining days were ok, there were some good
moments but mostly they were boring. I hated the morning chants so on 7th
and 9th I sneaked to my room and slept just to be awaken by the breakfast call at 6:30.
As far as discourses and instructions are
concerned the former can be entertaining a little informative as well (I am
refraining from using the term knowledge) but the later is certainly monotonous
and irritating.
I would also like to comment on the secular
nature of the course. Everyday during the discourse it is stressed that the
course is secular. The course certainly doesn’t ask you to be a Buddhist and
the teacher himself (S.N. Goenka) is Hindu but it talks about Buddha’s teaching
and how he was the only one to offer this experience etc. so I would say you
can call it biased. The stories are from Jatakas and are popular among the
buddhist community but like many religious stories most of them does not seem
logical.
After the mornings “Addithana” sitting on the
10th day the noble silence was lifted outside the meditation hall and
immediately the silent environment burst in laughter and chattering. Everyone
was sharing information with another. Everyone I talked to with exceptions of
the ones who had done the courses 5 times, 10 times or 25 times were sharing
how much peace they felt, and how they felt different etc. It reminded me of my
first course. I had to validate my decision and make it look meaningful and
fruitful, I was blowing up my experience. It was not intentional and I realized
it only after few weeks of practicing, I had not changed and I had not
experienced anything different. The only new thing I had was a technique to do
meditation, I had more information.
I have no doubt that the movement was put on
motion by Goenka with selflessness and to help others because it had helped
him, his mother and he had seen it help others. I am myself not very spiritual
person and I need to have logical explanation of things. I can’t follow others for
what they simply say. The thing that I enjoy in Vipassana is the detachment
from the World for few days, it gives me ample amount of time to introspect and
maybe unknowingly brings change in my behaviour due to this introspection. As
far as meditation itself is concerned, everyone is different, I haven’t been
able to believe that it can connect one with the truth and make realize there
is something beyond you that is omnipotent or anything.
If one needs meditation to be compassionate, to
be humble then I think that person can never be compassionate and humble. We
are however human and we misunderstand things, make wrong judgments so introspection
and analysis can make one realise their mistake and look at the larger picture.